My first word as a baby was “No.” Eventually, I learned more and longer words, and amused adults with my sesquipedalian vocabulary. Now that I’m a parent, “no” is once again my favorite word. I know many parents have written about the empowerment that comes with saying “Yes,” and I’m not disagreeing with the notion that parents should let their kids do wild n’ crazy stuff once in a while rather than automatically shut down the kid’s request. But in my quest to raise semi-civilized human beings, there are plenty of reasons I say no throughout the day:
- Safety: Obvious, right? We would prefer our kids survive to adulthood, preferably with all limbs and organs intact. “No, you may not climb onto the roof of your playset. No, you may not dash out into the traffic-laden road.” And yet, even here there’s room for disagreement; I have been criticized more than once for allowing my kids to do something that I deem reasonable but that others consider unacceptably dangerous, while others think I’m mollycoddling my offspring.
- Courtesy: I hope for my children to grow up to be moral, loving, brilliant, successful, well-adjusted people. Failing that, “semi-civilized” (see above) would be nice. “No, you may not poke your sister in the eye. No, you may not ride your younger brother; look, he’s crying and struggling to escape. No, you may not steal Daddy’s food. No, you may not go visit the diners at the next table. No, you may not lick your uncle.” I’m probably stifling their unique, golden personalities every time I forbid them to strip down nude and pee in the driveway, but how else am I going to turn them into soulless automatons that do whatever The Man tells them to do?
- Logistics: A fancy word for “I really don’t want to deal with the hassle of saying ‘yes’ to that request.” This is a more selfish reason for saying “no” than the two listed above; letting the kiddos “help” me bake is a fun activity that builds their kitchen skills, confidence, and ability to follow directions while spending quality time with me, but sometimes I just can’t face the mountains of flour that I know will be spilled all over the floor, or the egg bits that I will be fishing out of the stove crevices. “No, you may not paint right now. No, you may not get all 2,356 of your stuffed animals out of the cupboard, because I know who’ll wind up putting them away.” Selfish reasons for saying “no” may serve a parenting purpose, too; my kids are incredibly fortunate and lack nothing, and it’s important that they realize that sometimes they don’t get what they want. (You may insert your own snide comment about entitled Millennials, although many of you reading will be in that unfairly-maligned generation.)
- Precedent: Every parent knows how long a memory a child can have when it comes to events that they would like to see repeated. The reason nearly all parenting advice sites harp on consistency, consistency, consistency, is that kids will remember FOREVER that one time you said, oh, heck with it, you can jump on the bed, just make sure you don’t break something; just this one time probably won’t kill the springs. And if you offer treats on a given occasion, prepare for your children to cite said offering in the manner of a lawyer digging up judicial decisions from 150 years ago. “No, you can’t have ice cream while we’re at the pool. No, we’re not buying doughnuts at the grocery store. No, you can’t have a new ball from the drugstore.” Sometimes it gives me a great deal of pleasure to buy ice cream at the pool, I’m always up for doughnuts, and the kids love cheap, crappy plastic balls, but I want to limit how much clamoring for treats my children will aim at me each and every time we go somewhere. And if I’m really too exhausted to enforce a rule that I know I ought to be enforcing…well, I can always pretend that I didn’t see them jumping on the bed, because I TOTALLY WOULD HAVE put a stop to that nonsense if only I’d been aware of it.
- Cruelty. I feed off the tears of disappointed infants. Not really, but I’m sure my kids think so at times. Look, dear ones, one of these days you might have messy little savages of your own to cherish, and when you do, I think you’ll appreciate the magical powers of that delightful word, “No.”